40868f2c8263431baa6977c9a3f826fa_18

It’s a man’s game

My main thought during State of Play: woah these are some dedicated and passionate boy gamers; woah those are some dedicated and passionate fangirls.

 

 

State of Play is a documentary that looks into the eSports profession in South Korea. It is centered not so much around the actual gaming, but more so around the hysteria that exists within the gaming industry: the fans, the hours of training, the huge stadiums, the money, the sacrifices the gamers make and, overall, the intense and fierce nature of the eSports scene.

But, to me, what was most prevalent within the documentary was how glaringly obvious the gender roles were. Men are the talented, moneymaking gamers; women are the screaming, adoring fans. My lack of knowledge and exposure to the gaming industry prevents me from knowing too much in this area, but what isn’t obvious throughout the documentary is whether girls even try to compete at a professional level, whether any of them are interested, whether they just accept the gender norms, or if there are girls out there who are frustrated by the fact that men dominate the gaming industry and they are expected to just scream and squeal for the boys until their throats are sore, at which point they just fall to their knees and present the gamers with gifts, even when they’ve lost.

After researching into the area of autoethnography, it is interesting to consider how my passion for feminism and gender equality effects my viewing of State of Play. Being asked to observe and record my perspectives when watching the film and then consider how my cultural biases and experiences forms my opinion, it makes me wonder whether other people around the world view the film the same way as I do. In particular, do women in Korea watch the film and are completely oblivious to the gender divide purely because that’s all they know and that’s all their culture is used to?

“Autoethnography is an approach to research and writing that seeks to describe and systematically analyze (graphy) personal experience (auto) in order to understand cultural experience (ethno)” (Ellis et al. 2011).

In this way, the researcher makes themselves the subject of research by using their thoughts and observations.

So, by describing and analyzing my personal experience of women empowerment in order to understand the cultural experience of South Korean gaming, it is obvious that I am watching this film as an outsider, completely amazed and confused by the industry purely because of my cultural differences and experiences. I am used to, coming from Western culture, people expecting women to be involved in areas that men are also. It shocks me seeing women being completely put into submissive roles of fandom and no one questioning it. And that is my understanding of autoethnography: my experiences affecting my viewing.

I’d like to add that I do not speak poorly of gaming or the talent and passion of gamers. (This is me personally looking into an industry that I know little about: I watch the gamers’ fingers tap against the keyboard hundreds of times a minute in awe). Rather, I am impressed by the gamers and encouraging of anyone who can make money where people don’t typically think there should be money. I’d just like to see some female hands holding that money too.

Advertisements

5 comments

  1. Hey, great start to your autoethnographic experience, you’re already onto the critical analysis! I like that you looked into gender roles and the glaringly obvious but unquestioned gender disparity in State Of Play. I think you nailed the whole tone of the documentary when you said it was about the ‘hysteria’ that surrounds the entire phenomenon rather than the actual game itself. I also like that you brought up that the documentary itself didn’t focus on gender inequality, but does that mean the entire culture is complacent with women in submissive roles? Feminism is everywhere, and it certainly is in South Korea (like the case study Chris showed us with Megalian), just perhaps not in this documentary. It would be interesting to see the general role feminism plays in South Korea and in esports. In Western Culture I would agree that a lot of people expect women to be involved in the same areas as men, but women are still relatively shut out of gaming in Western culture too, no? (see Anita Sarkeesian: https://www.youtube.com/user/feministfrequency/videos). Gaming culture is also a global phenomenon, as the documentary touched on with the esports going to America, so it would be interesting to see where it intersects with different cultural groups. I look forward to seeing your critical analysis in the next post!

    Liked by 1 person

  2. I couldn’t agree more! When watching State of Play I was also pretty amazed at the strong gender roles in place in eSports. I’m embarrased to admit that I hadn’t however consider whether any women in South Korea were annoyed by the gap too, I had just assumed that they were. In Western culture we have a similar disparity in gaming, however there is more of an outcry against the gender gap. Really well written and emersive blog post, you have a strong writing voice and this was a delight to read!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. thank you so much for your feedback. so lovely to hear 🙂 its interesting hey that we just assume that all women around the world expect equality, but perhaps some women dont even consider it, just because that’s all theyve ever known whereas you and I grew up expecting to get the same privileges that men get. i guess that’s a part of autoethnography – assumptions because of our culture and experiences.

      Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s